Navigation

Skiplink Navigation

Main Features

Mental health Report highlights depression gulf between Swiss language regions

A stress echocardiography is carried out to determine why a patient suffered a breakdown. Photo taken at the Ospidal Val Muestair hospital in Santa Maria in canton Graubünden in 2012

(Keystone)

French and Italian-speaking residents report suffering from depression at a rate almost double that of German-speakers, according to a Swiss newspaper citing the most recent federal health statistics. 

According to a report by Le Matin Dimanche, French and Italian-speakers suffer from much higher rates of depression (8.9% of the population) than German speakers (5.5%). 

The report, which is based on statistics from the most recent Swiss health survey in 2012, said the highest rate was recorded in canton Vaud (10.1%) versus 1.6% in canton Uri in central Switzerland. The alpine nation has a population of 8.3 million. 

The contrast between French/Italian-speaking and German-speaking women was even more stark: 10.9% versus 5.7%. Around 7% of people in towns and cities were said to be depressed, compared to 5.4% in rural areas. 

No federal reports exist to explain these differences. The Le Matin Dimanche report suggests that the variations are caused by greater urbanisation, higher unemployment rates, and a greater willingness to discuss the taboo mental health issue in French and Italian-speaking regions. 

According to the Federal Statistical Office, French- and Italian-speakers visit doctors more often than German-speakers (8% of the population visited five or more times in 2012 versus 6.3%). 

Erich Seifritz, chief physician at the Psychiatric University Hospital in Zurich, told the paper that the high concentration of psychiatrists in French- and Italian-speaking regions did not explain the variation: "It is possible that regional attitudes to mental illness may be different.” 

He added that taboos around depression in German-speaking regions "prevent many people from asking for help”, which means many people do not get proper treatment. 

The report said a study cited in BMC Medicine magazine in 2011 showed that France was the European country with the highest rates of depression (21%). The figure for neighbouring Germany was 9.9%.  

swissinfo.ch/sb

Neuer Inhalt

Horizontal Line


subscription form

Form for signing up for free newsletter.

Sign up for our free newsletters and get the top stories delivered to your inbox.







Click here to see more newsletters

swissinfo EN

The following content is sourced from external partners. We cannot guarantee that it is suitable for the visually or hearing impaired.

Join us on Facebook!

×